Use final open source configuration to build release. Top 10 gnu gpl license questions answered whitesource. Dont believe the hype, agpl open source licensing is toxic and unpopular by matt asay matt asay is a veteran technology columnist who has written for cnet. The gnu general public license permits making a modified version and letting the public access it on a server without ever releasing its source code to the public. For gpl programs running on your server, you are the user, for agpl, the real users of the app are the users of your website or service. For the affero gpl, your obligations are the same as for the gpl unless if you modify the server software.
The gnu affero general public license is based on the gnu gpl, but has an additional term to allow users who interact with the licensed software over a network to receive the source for that program. Its then up to you to cease and desist or to argue that your use does not violate the license. And because no one can ever redistribute without a license, we can safely presume that anyone redistributing gpld software intended to accept the gpl. Sep 03, 2016 gpl, also known as copyleft, grants permission to reuse or modify the source code to make derivative works, but if you distribute your program to others, it requires you to license your derivative work under the gpl too. The affero general public license affero gpl and informally affero license is a free software license. Sep 05, 2017 reading black duck softwares newest paean to the affero general public license agpl the quietly accelerating adoption of the agpl, one could be forgiven for thinking agpl is rocking the. Tldrlegal software licenses explained in plain english. Similar to the agpl, the open software licenses requires you to disclose your source code. What is the difference between gpl, agpl and lgpl licenses. Use debug open source configuration to debug be prepared, its very slow. How does rstudio desktop opensource and commercial licenses. With the third iteration of the most popular open source license, the free software foundation tackled weighty questions relating to software patents, license compatibility. But most open source licenses impose no conditions on internal use of software. This is harmful to user freedom because it lets future development be taken out of the public domain and instead moved into nonfree programs.
Sep 14, 2017 in many settings, open source licensing today is considered a solved problem. Jan 23, 2020 rstudio is available under the gnu affero general public license v3. Note that it is a copyleft license, unlike the nearly identical academic free license made by the same author. The affero general public license is a free software license. Open source licenses grant permission for anybody to use, modify, and share licensed software for any purpose, subject to conditions preserving the provenance and openness of the software. The agpl v3 is an opensource license that guarantees the freedom to share and change the software, and to make sure. The gnu affero general public license version 3 agplv3 is a copyleft. In my opinion, the three possible reasons are as follows. Gnu general public license version 3 open source initiative. However, not being a lawyer, and actually not having read the whole license, i cant understand what exactly you can do freely and what. The gnu affero general public license gnu agpl is a modified version of. This is a brief explanation of how to place a program under the gnu general public license, gnu lesser general public license, or gnu affero general. Sep 10, 2001 and because no one can ever redistribute without a license, we can safely presume that anyone redistributing gpld software intended to accept the gpl. This provision requires that the full source code be made available to any network user of the agpllicensed.
This is an incomplete list of software that are licensed under the gnu affero general public license, in alphabetical order akvo platform data platform for sustainable development goals and international. Gnu affero general public license version 3 open source. If you break an opensource license, the authors of the software would have remedies under law. How to choose the best license for your open source software. Facebook uses fooproject in an internal project, facebookinternal, thats not exposed to the internet, but does not open source facebookinternal with agpl. Therefore you are distributing the app if someone other. The open source initiative maintains a list of approved open source licenses, which comply with the osis definition of open source. Effortlessly track and comply with your open source.
Gpl requires you to release the source code of your application if. Rstudio is available under the gnu affero general public license v3. Lookup popular software licenses summarized ataglance. The relevant part of the agpl is as follows emphasis added.
The gnu affero general public license version 3 agplv3 is a copyleft license nearly identical to the gplv3. The apache license, on the other hand, is favored by the big corporations for. Apr 17, 2010 the agpl makes straightforward commercial sense we use it for our open source product, flint. It also does not tell them what other software may be running on that server, examining or changing their data in other ways. Commercial licenses are also available from mongodb, inc. The gnulgpl is very popular among independent developers and companies which mainly deal with open source software. How to choose the best license for your open source. Why the gnu affero gpl gnu project free software foundation. This is an incomplete list of software that are licensed under the gnu affero general public license, in alphabetical order. The agpl v3 is an opensource license that guarantees the freedom to share and change the software, and to make sure it remains free software for all its users. If a server program is licensed with an open source license, the license terms apply to the server software itself, not to your own files that you host using that server.
Today, the gpl license that stallman pioneered is in its third version and is only one of several dozen types of open source licenses. Its terms effectively consist of the terms of gplv3, with an additional paragraph in section to allow users who interact with the licensed software over a network to receive the source for that program. It also does not tell them what other software may be running on that server, examining or. When the reforged gnu general public license, version 3 gplv3 was finalized and released to an expectant public on june 29, 2007, the most important decision may have been one. May 30, 2019 sspl is a perfectly serviceable open source license, and like gpl and agpl, rather than prohibit software from being run as a service, sspl requires that you open source all programs that you use. Jul 24, 2018 when the copyleft agpl was first published, many leaders in the open source community had something to say about the issue of a supposed loophole in the gpl open source license that allowed saas companies to integrate gpl open source libraries without sharing their code. Effortlessly track and comply with your open source licenses. Agpl is a fairly new license that was meant to go gplovernetworks. In june 2015, i discovered that itext was used in a closed source module that served as an addon to closed source accounting software.
Dont believe the hype, agpl open source licensing is. Gnu affero general public license version 3 open source initiative. Various licenses and comments about them gnu project. The first version of the affero general public license agplv1, was published by affero, inc. This fork has been created to ensure that itext 5 will stay maintained, since the itext company. This is an incomplete list of software that are licensed under the gnu affero general public license, in alphabetical order akvo platform data platform for sustainable development goals and international development tracking. Dont believe the hype, agpl open source licensing is toxic. Gnu project the gnu operating system and the free software. Spdx license list software package data exchange spdx. A main program that is separate from its plugins makes no requirements for the plugins. It keeps your code bona fide open source, so people who want to use and extend it noncommercially can do so without worrying about you at all. In the osis own words, these licenses allow software to be. The agpl makes straightforward commercial sense we use it. What agpl does on top of gpl is the redefinition of user.
Nov 08, 2015 linus torvalds says gpl v3 violates everything that gplv2 stood for duration. We recommend that people consider using the gnu agpl for any software which will commonly be run over a network. Frequently asked questions about the gnu licenses gnu. Enforcing the gnu gpl gnu project free software foundation. The purpose of the spdx license list is to enable easy and efficient identification of such licenses and exceptions in an spdx document, in source files or elsewhere. For gpl programs running on your server, you are the user, for agpl, the real. Rstudio also offers a commercial desktop license for rstudio and a commercial license for rstudio server pro. The mitexpat license doesnt protect against open source code being taken without payment and used in proprietary software. By contrast, the gnu general public license is intended to guarantee your freedom to share and change all versions of a programto make sure it remains free software for all its users. In many settings, open source licensing today is considered a solved problem. Google open source guru chris dibona says that the web giant continues to ban the lightningrod agpl open source license within the company because doing so saves engineering.
The spdx license list is a list of commonly found licenses and exceptions used in free and open source and other collaborative software or documentation. Linus torvalds says gpl v3 violates everything that gplv2 stood for duration. This is absolutely not the way we conceive open source and we want to. Gpl, also known as copyleft, grants permission to reuse or modify the source code to make derivative works, but if you distribute your program to others, it requires you to license your. So, internal controls developed in the early 2000s usually.
If the main program and the plugins are a single combined program then this means you must license the plugin under the gpl or a gplcompatible free software license and distribute it with source code in a. If the main program and the plugins are a single combined program then this means you must license the plugin under the gpl or a gplcompatible free software license and distribute it with source code in a gplcompliant way. This is harmful to user freedom because it lets future. Software licenses in plain english lookup popular software licenses summarized ataglance. May i use agpl license in a desktop application without. Feb 24, 2020 the open source initiative maintains a list of approved open source licenses, which comply with the osis definition of open source. Agpl what you can do and what you cant software engineering. There is an earlier open source license known as the affero general public license that was not published by the free software foundation, which is not addressed in this article. The example of the accounting software and the pdf invoices wasnt chosen at random.
Let us examine why these corporations stay away from gpl and favor the apache license. What happens to those who break open source license. After all, the gpl requires each copy of covered software to include the license text, so everyone is fully informed. The gnulgpl is very popular among independent developers and companies which mainly deals with open source software. The apache license, on the other hand, is favored by the big corporations for their open source projects. Having said that, the agpl helps ensure that software is kept open source by making it more difficult to take other peoples open source code, extend it, and withholding the changes while. The agpl is the closest thing possible to a proprietary software license. Both licenses have the same copyleft scope, but materially differ in one.
Distribution unlike most other open source licenses, agpls conditions are not all dependent on redistribution of the software. Which open source license is best for commercialization. Jan 18, 2017 ohhhh, now i get itthis is an attempt to make modify in the agpl mean something different from modify in the gpl itself, such that you can do things that would be considered modifying in the gpl and hence trigger copyleft and claim they dont constitute modifying for purposes of the extra proviso in the agpl and hence wont trigger copyleft, so you can incorporate agpl code into. Sspl is a perfectly serviceable opensource license, and like gpl and agpl, rather than prohibit software from being run as a service, sspl requires that you opensource all programs that. Its terms effectively consist of the terms of gplv3, with an additional paragraph in section to allow users. Why corporations favors the apache license over the gpllgpl. Gpl and lgpl open source licensing restrictions stack. That is good, but having this source code does not give them control over the computing done on that server. In most cases where people use separate gpl applications in closed source. For most other open source licenses like gpl, the condition for making source code available is the distribution of the software.
How does rstudio desktop opensource and commercial. Similar to the agpl, the open software licenses requires you to disclose your source code when you communicate software which includes cloudhosted distribution. To get around this, licenses such as the gnu affero general public license agpl have a stipulation that users who access the software over a network are also entitled to receive the source code. We dont see any sensible way to address the saass problem with license conditions on particular programs. Openpdf5 is an open source library for pdf files, maintained in accordance with the agpl license. The mitexpat license doesnt protect against opensource code being taken without payment and used in proprietary software. Gnu affero general public license agpl version 3 this is a free software, copyleft license.
Lgpl allows you to use and distribute the open source software with your application without releasing the source code for your application. Should they choose to try to enforce them, the first step would be to have a lawyer send you a. Dont believe the hype, agpl open source licensing is toxic and. For most other open source licenses like gpl, the condition for making. Not only has the open source initiative osi largely contained the long feared issue of license proliferation, the industry has essentially consolidated around a few reasonably well understood models. Interpretation of agpl with shiny server open source stack. Not only has the open source initiative osi largely contained the long feared issue of license proliferation, the. Apr 15, 2009 when the reforged gnu general public license, version 3 gplv3 was finalized and released to an expectant public on june 29, 2007, the most important decision may have been one postponed. For entry level projects, it is commonly feared that choosing more restrictive i. Copyleft licenses such as the gpl, which require users who would distribute the software. Openpdf5 is a fork of itext 5, maintained in accordance with the agpl open source license.
Despite the fud, as a license the gpl is absolutely solid. Im the original developer of itext, an open source pdf library released as agpl software. This page is intended to provide a summary of information that may prove useful in understanding agpl licensing of artifex products. If you break an open source license, the authors of the software would have remedies under law. Gnu affero general public license gnu project free software. The open source initiative, an organization founded in 1998 to promote open source software and normalize the use of the term, has approved more than 80 open source licenses. Should they choose to try to enforce them, the first step would be to have a lawyer send you a cease and desist letter. We, the free software foundation, use the gnu general public license for most of our software. Openpdf5 is a maintained fork of itext 5, and is licensed as agpl software. The gnu affero general public license is designed specifically to ensure that, in such cases, the modified source code becomes available to the community. Software licensing gpl agpl bsd mit apache eula youtube. The licenses for most software and other practical works are designed to take away your freedom to share and change the works.
1462 308 49 529 1000 367 485 590 182 1050 263 1481 1507 606 1596 352 1243 876 81 264 489 1371 333 1577 1213 1206 404 1623 477 86 935 1 991 152 1373 1084 414